Current:Home > MyVirginia court revives lawsuit by teacher fired for refusing to use transgender student’s pronouns -前500条预览:
Virginia court revives lawsuit by teacher fired for refusing to use transgender student’s pronouns
View
Date:2025-04-24 13:39:02
RICHMOND, Va. (AP) — A lawsuit filed by a Virginia high school teacher who was fired after he refused to use a transgender student’s pronouns was reinstated Thursday by the state Supreme Court.
Peter Vlaming, a former French teacher at West Point High School, sued the school board and administrators at West Point High School after he was fired in 2018. A judge dismissed the lawsuit before any evidence was heard in the case. But the Supreme Court overturned that ruling and said the lawsuit can proceed to trial.
Vlaming claimed in his lawsuit that he tried to accommodate a transgender student in his class by using his masculine name and avoiding the use of pronouns, but the student, his parents and the school told him he was required to use the student’s male pronouns.
Vlaming said he could not use the student’s pronouns because of his “sincerely held religious and philosophical” beliefs “that each person’s sex is biologically fixed and cannot be changed.” Vlaming also said he would be lying if he used the student’s pronouns.
His lawsuit, brought by Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative Christian legal advocacy group, alleged that the school violated his constitutional right to speak freely and exercise his religion. The school board argued that Vlaming violated the school’s anti-discrimination policy.
All seven justices of the state Supreme Court agreed that two of Vlaming’s claims should move forward to trial: his claim that his right to freely exercise his religion was violated under the Virginia constitution and his breach of contract claim against the school board.
“Absent a truly compelling reason for doing so, no government committed to these principles can lawfully coerce its citizens into pledging verbal allegiance to ideological views that violate their sincerely held religious beliefs,” Justice D. Arthur Kelsey wrote in the majority opinion, joined by three other justices.
But the court was split on some aspects of the lawsuit. In a dissenting opinion, Justice Thomas Mann, joined by two other justices, wrote that the majority’s opinion on Vlaming’s free-exercise-of-religion claim was overly broad and “establishes a sweeping super scrutiny standard with the potential to shield any person’s objection to practically any policy or law by claiming a religious justification for their failure to follow either.”
L. Steven Emmert, an appellate attorney and publisher of the website Virginia Appellate News & Analysis, said the main dispute between the majority and the dissenting justices “is the extent to which the individual’s beliefs can overcome the government’s interests.”
“The majority said only where the public safety and order is at stake can the government restrict someone’s speech and their free exercise of religion, and this case doesn’t rise to that level,” Emmert said.
Vlaming’s attorney, Alliance Defending Freedom senior counsel Christopher Schandevel, said Vlaming was well-liked by his students and “did his best to accommodate their needs and requests.”
“But he couldn’t in good conscience speak messages that he doesn’t believe to be true, and no school board or government official can punish someone for that reason,” Schandevel said.
During arguments before the state Supreme Court in November 2002, Alan Schoenfeld, an attorney who represents the school board and school administrators, said Vlaming’s speech was part of his official teaching duties and his refusal to use the student’s pronouns clearly violated the anti-discrimination policy.
”A public school employee is not at liberty to declare that he will not comply with a neutrally applicable policy that is part of his duties as a classroom teacher,” he said.
Schoenfeld did not immediately respond to a telephone message Thursday. School board Chair Elliot Jenkins and Vice-Chair Laura Shreaves did not immediately respond to emails seeking comment on the ruling.
Alliance Defending Freedom has brought at least six similar lawsuits — three in Virginia, and one each in Ohio, Kansas and Indiana.
veryGood! (34225)
Related
- DeepSeek: Did a little known Chinese startup cause a 'Sputnik moment' for AI?
- Key Bridge cleanup crews begin removing containers from Dali cargo ship
- South Carolina, Iowa, UConn top final AP Top 25 women’s basketball poll to cap extraordinary season
- MLB's elbow injury problem 'getting worse' as aces Shane Bieber, Spencer Strider fall victim
- Kylie Jenner Shows Off Sweet Notes From Nieces Dream Kardashian & Chicago West
- An engine cover on a Southwest Airlines plane rips off, forcing the flight to return to Denver
- Jonathan Majors Sentenced to 52-Week Counseling Program in Domestic Violence Case
- What is Masters Par 3 Contest? A guide to the family-friendly pre-tournament event
- How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
- Why does South Carolina's Dawn Staley collect confetti? Tradition started in 2015
Ranking
- 'Kraven the Hunter' spoilers! Let's dig into that twisty ending, supervillain reveal
- ‘Red flag’ bill debated for hours in Maine months after mass shooting that killed 18
- Kelsea Ballerini and Chase Stokes Are Calling Dibs on a Date Night at CMT Music Awards
- Solar eclipse: NSYNC's Lance Bass explains how not to say 'bye bye bye to your vision'
- FACT FOCUS: Inspector general’s Jan. 6 report misrepresented as proof of FBI setup
- Is it safe to look at a total solar eclipse? What to know about glasses, proper viewing
- Toby Keith honored at 2024 CMT Awards with moving tribute from Sammy Hagar, Lainey Wilson
- Yes, dogs can understand, link objects to words, researchers say
Recommendation
At site of suspected mass killings, Syrians recall horrors, hope for answers
2044 solar eclipse path: See where in US totality hits in next eclipse
Mexico's president says country will break diplomatic ties with Ecuador
Missouri to reduce risk of suffering if man requires surgical procedure at execution
South Korea's acting president moves to reassure allies, calm markets after Yoon impeachment
California doctor travels to Gaza to treat children injured in Israel-Hamas war
Lauren Graham Reveals Matthew Perry's Final Birthday Gift to Her
Morgan Wallen has been arrested after police say he threw a chair off of the roof of a 6-story bar